If you were to ask me who I was most attracted to of all the Buffyverse types it would… well it would probably be one of two people.  Maybe three.  Typically dictated by what I had seen most recently.  But that means whole series done, which is the state I usually am at, the answer is usually going to be Emma Caulfield, which I think puts my significantly outside the norm.  Not that people talk about her being ugly or anything it’s just that is she has legions of people who think she was the hottest on Buffy they are a silent legion.  But I always found her attractive.  The most attractive.  I am not entirely sure why.  There is something to be said for Anya herself.  From an analytical perspective arguments have been made she was the only truly sexually liberated female on the show, in that she was never punished for transgressing the allowed role of female sexuality.  That’s a whole thing though and I would argue it is not entirely true.  But also, things got bleak late in the show, a lot of angst and stuff and it made Anya one of the few bright spots, if she was in a scene it was usually a lot more fun.  Of course, I specifically watched a movie called Timer just because Emma Caulfield was in it and that had nothing to do with Anya, so maybe I just find her really pretty and she has that thing that appeals to me.  Who knows.  I don’t.  I just know that today I want to fuck Emma Caulfield.